Witter has the most accurate statement of any of them:

"De la Hoya is best against people who are coming forward, he is an excellent counter-puncher. But with the style Mayweather has got, he’s not going to rush into anything and make that mistake that de la Hoya needs."
This is what the whole fight boils down to in my opinion, and it's the reason I've been picking Floyd all along. This fight isn't about age or size, it's about fighting styles. Floyd's style is a very bad matchup for Oscar.
Oscar has always been at his best when he's in the ring with a big puncher who will try to stalk him, which forces Oscar into the role of fast counter-puncher.
It's no surprise that Oscar's best performances were against Vargas, Mayorga, the first 9 rounds against Tito....