Quote Originally Posted by jbirdy
i'm thinking that because that new girl on the island told hurley that the oceanic flight 815 had been found and there was no survivors. maybe the limbo theory might be the case. but im also thinking that maybe the government experiment theory could be the case. the government could have covered it up and claimed that they found the crashed plane. hmmmmmmm.
and was i the only one who was shouting at the screen when the rusian fella got zapped by the invisible electric field fence thing and no one actually checked if he was dead?
i'm loving this show, its the only thing i wont miss.
na mate, you aint the only one who had major doubts mickel was dead

Quote Originally Posted by Preme
'The list' if you remember Ben said he was heading to their camp to bring people back, John was one of them, he told John when they were in the hatch, he said then the leader was a magnificent man and it wasn't him. Yeah they know everything about every one, this lives, girlfirends, basically if you paid a girl you never seen before in your life to do some kinky S*** with you, told her a false name, never told anyone again THEY KNOW!

I'm still not certain about the leader yet, Jacks dad may be it, Desmond's bitches also - but it think the fathers, suns, jacks/Clair's, Desi's bitch are all more of the higher council of this.

I'm still thinking that this Island is some sort of secret government type research centre - a place where PETA and the rest of the human/animal right nuts don't know about, a place where 'frownd upon' methods stateside would be opposed and banned. Was this the 'way' Jacks dad mentioned to let Claire's mum die? will we see Claire's mum saved and amongst them!?!

anyone else uncertain of weather patchy was dead? no one checked his F****** pulse! a lil bit of spit up was about all we seen? i mean F*** you could leg it through them sensors fast enough surly?
Lastly, has John been compremised? blowing up the Flame, throwing patchy to his death - he isn't stupid, he found the C4 (somehow?) so knew it was wired, that black chick wanted to die so he knew that them being alive was something to their advantage yet he throws him through there!

it's no suprise to see Jack 'enjoying' him self there, its either 1 of 2 things IMO - its a plan to act like it buy his time and work out what he needs to do, or they have let him in on whats what (maybe meet his dad if he is in on this?) and they really are 'the good guys'

On a side note, good news and bad news i guess, good news is it is still possible for that moaning lil manc twat charlie still may die, bad news is the prick hasn't yet! and yeah, Claire looked well fit in her goth gear!
I'm not buying into this 'everyone is dead and in limbo' thing either... There was a time when i thought it was possible and that it was the final step to get into heaven or hell - but to many things now make it not possible IMO.

Juliet came to the Island alive and out of free will, she isn't dead! Benn said he would let Her and jack go HOME, surly he can't let dead people go back to being alive? he said him self he was going to let them go but didn't want Jack to.

Benn has lived his entire life on the Island, we are meant to believe what, he died as a baby and grew up there, DEAD? why would a dead person have a tumor on their spine?

If 'The others' are meant to be the gate keeprs or the final test, then they would know surly, about everyone who was coming to the Island, they seem to know of noone untill they arive and give them selves away.

How could desmonds chick have found him, or get a rough idea of where he is if he was dead? i mean 'if you have enough money you can find anyone' but in limbo? thats stretching it?