if anyone seriously thinks magarito would beat floyd think again oscar was much better opponent than magarito and floyd beat him ok not in the most convincing manor but he still got the job done floyd would elude tony all night and pick him off. the only person who i can see give floyd a test is mosley thats it. as for if floyd is an all time great he may not be in the top 10 but he isin't far off in my opinion if he does come back out of his retirement to fight SSM and beats him and say beat any other top contender i'd put him as an all time great.