If Floyd had put on a clinic there would be no need for a rematch. But De La Hoya fought a great fight & although I thought Floyd won 115 - 114 (would have been happy with a draw) there are enough questions to warrant a rematch.

Floyd seems to give the fans what they want. When his 1st fight with Castillo called for a rematch he granted it. I see him making one here too. If Floyd leaves without giving Oscar another shot it will affect his legacy. Sorta like Lewis/ V. Klitschko. There were enough questions still left floating after that one. (I think Lewis woulda cleaned him up though if the fight continued)