Who wins the Cotto - Judah - Margo - Williams mini tournament.

[tedsares]

I think the real question is will they actually go through with it...

How do you guys see it playing out and why?

Williams svages Maragrito and ko's Cotto....I hope.

[Hairdoo]

good points from everyone. Either way, does anyone think Floyd will fight the winner of this tournament? Even if the winner is....dare I say...Margarito?

yeh I hadn't really considered it.

It wouldn't look good for Floyd knocking back $8 mil claiming Tony is a nobody when he is ranked Ring Magazines no.1 Welterweight and has cleaned out the division.

[CutMeMick]

Since PBF fought at Light. Midd. and therefor his status at Welter shifts to that div. heres how I rate the Welters....

1. Margarito - His longevity in the div. plus being a 2-time WBO Champ. working on his 8th defense of the title earns him this spot.

2. Cotto - He moves up to Welter and takes on a natural 147 lber. wins the title and automatically takes on his mandatory.

3. Baldomir - The sh*t! he did last year was insane and talk about being at the right at the right time. After his loss that drops him off here.

4. SSM - His last 4 fights have been at a catch weight, warm up fights if you will. He then messes up his status and fights Vargas at a catch weight. He comes to 147 and beats Collazo soundly.

5. Williams - Hes moved up too slow IMO, but hes here now and it's to time to step it up and show what hes got.

[shza]

Here's how I see the potential match-ups:

Most likely:
Judah beats Cotto
Margarito beats Williams
Margarito beats Judah

Next most likely:
Cotto beats Judah
Margarito beats Williams
Cotto beats Margarito

Really, I think Cotto is the guy Judah has the best chance at beating, because Cotto's smaller than the other guys, and Judah can beat him from the outside. He can't beat the other two from the outside. And I don't pick him to win fights on the inside.

Conversely, I think Judah is the guy Cotto is least likely to beat, but I'd pick Cotto over either Margarito or Williams.

Finally, I like Williams (and I can't stand Margarito), but I don't think he's ready for Margarito. Same style (i.e., undisciplined, wide, and 100% offensive), probably more skilled, but way less experienced (sure he's had almost as many fights, but the level's really not there).

But I also like Meowza's scenario. And I agree that Clottey beats Margarito in a rematch.

[Pugilistic]

its hard to decide but i think judah

[CutMeMick]

For the record I think Cotto wins the little tourney....

[Unknowndonor]

It's a toss up. I'd say that if Cotto beats Zab, he has the edge, but a "war" with Tony might be his undoing.

Lets just all hold our breath and hope Floyd fights the winner.

[SweetPea]

At this moment, I'd predict Cotto to win a mini-tournament, but I have to say that I think we should all wait until we see the two fights coming up.

Cotto/Judah and Margarito/Williams will tell us a TON about each fighter.

[LegendBoxing65]

I think it is between Margarito and Williams. Judah's chin will not hold up to Margarito or Williams.

[Ice Man]

Zab beats Cotto

Tony and Williams is a toss up

but if Tony wins Zab will win, his hooks are just to wide and easy to duck and counter.

if williams wins, he may have what it takes to beat Zab, but Zab has had better opposition and more experience...

but my money's on Zab

[SalTheButcher]

Mann ..I like cotto.. But im gona have to say judah..

In fact..If this tournament..Is actually a tounament.. then i really want to see judah - williams..I think thats a great fight..Strange but interesting..

Thing is im not sure..Is it an official tournament...

Because in all fairness i think its just cotto and margarito that wanted to fight eachother to unify..

Margarito had to fight paul williams his mandatory.. and so cotto went off to find a great fight inbetweens..

Alot of people are assuming both margarito and cotto will both win these fights, they have to for each other to stay interested in the fight and for the fight to actually be a unification..

Problem both theyr oponents are very good fighters.. And it might not come off that way.. I wouldnt put big money on the results of either fight..

Im sure all four have actually thought of this..Whether this is considered officially as a mini tourni or not im sure all fighters will have considered facing the winner of the other bout for unification purposes..

But i tip zab judah to beat cotto..Unfortunately by stoppage..
Then its basically a throw up for margarito - williams..

Is margarito over hyped.. Then again is williams?
Margarito doesnt seem like an incredible boxer?.. Could he get out boxed?
Williams has never faced someone with the power of Tony..Can he take a lick?

Promising stuff dont you think?

Yeah, it's like pitting all the elements against each other.
Water beats fire, but fire beats wood. But wood beats water... What element comes out on top?
It's kind of like the heavyweight picture, except it's interesting.

i belivee that water KTFO wood, its a slow process of corrosion, but it will happen, thats like water outboxing wood

[bzkfn]

Cotto all the way.

How are you expecting Zab to knock Cotto out? Zab was all different flavours of shite against Baldo and Floyd and I don't think he would have knocked Spinks out had Spinks not stopped to look at the referee. Zab is waaaaaaaaaaay overrated. Cotto to destroy him.

I also don't really see whats so special about Margo...but I've mentioned that a million times on this forum.

Williams to beat him and then lose to Cotto.

Cotto beats Floyd and then challenges Butterbean and loses when the Bean sits on him for the 10 count.

[bzkfn]

For the record I think Cotto wins the little tourney....

You are correct

[Tito BHB]

At this moment, I'd predict Cotto to win a mini-tournament, but I have to say that I think we should all wait until we see the two fights coming up.

Cotto/Judah and Margarito/Williams will tell us a TON about each fighter.

Cc.. Ive said that there is Alot!! That is uncertain about how this tourni is going down..

But you hit the nail on the head with that one.. The one thing that is certain..Is that this tournament will tell us alot about each fighter..

This is all four fighter's biggest fights to date!

[ICB]

Judah beats Cotto.
Cotto beats Judah in a rematch.
There's no rubber match.

Meanwhile, Margarito beats Williams.
While Cotto and Judah are having their rematch, Margarito and Clottey get it on for their anticipated rematch.
Clottey upsets Margarito in their rematch.

Floyd beats Mosley during this time.

Clottey fights Cotto.
Cotto beats Clottey.

Cotto wants a shot at Floyd.
Floyd says Cotto lost to Judah, a man he beat, and denies him of a fight.

Floyd tries for the 160 WBC belt against Spinks who upsets Taylor Saturday.

Ha yea right