Quote Originally Posted by wacko3205
Quote Originally Posted by Preme
Has the time finaly come for taylor to be taken off the P4P list?

I know he 'beat' hopkins twice all those years ago and 'drew' with a light-middleweight, but surly he can't keep hanging on to those 'wins'?

I used to be a big fan of Taylor,maybe bought into the hype, i thought he was gunna be a breath of fresh air, nice humble guy, who was hungry and wanted to clean out his division, but since he has been champ he has only fought ONE middleweight, defended his belt 3 times against light-middle's and looked shite doing so.

In his last two fights Taylor has not looked deserving of a place in a top 20 P4P list, yet he is still ranked fairlyhigh in our list.
As far as a P4P list goes & Taylor's status & slot on one...well...you have to think with your head & not your heart.

He won...whether you liked the way he did it or not...he did. He's still undefeated & he keeps on working as the champion...so yeah...he stays on the list.

Personally, I will (...till the day I'm toes up takin a gotdam dirt nap) keep my resolve & use common sense in stating that he lost the first match to Hopkins & he lost to Wright. Sorry folks...fan or not...he did lose those fights.
but thinking with my head, yeah he has won his last 2 fights.. but looked crap doing so. Just because you win doesn't mean you should be p4p...

He just JUST beat a guy alot smaller than him, alot weaker than him... a guy who willmostlikely go back down and stay at light-middle... a guy who isn't even a p4p fighter...

Hatton and Castillo got droppd off p4plists for a hell of alot less... There are alot more deserving people out there of his spot IMO.