Hi there, Roy is the best in his comfortable weight. No question about that but not to say he can't be beaten. He hasn't just met someone who could cancel out his speed and physical prowess during his time. Because clearly he has dominated that era thru that qualities. His defense is not good because his hands are lackadaisically lowered down and he can afford to do this because he has no opponent can match his superior speed and reflex aduring that time. But what if he met someone like for example juan manuel marquez who is sharpshooter and clearly has superior refflex than he has. I don't think lowering both his hands down would just give him 20 less hits in a fight. However, floyd is of different breed than roy as a fighter. and yes he is extraordinary too. Although roy's imposing speed,power and physically prowess in his time is the main reason of greatness. Floyd is more of a complete fighter than roy will ever be. Floyd, has speed,good power,physical prowess,stamina,great reflex, and more so far more intelligent than roy. I think one area of why roy is partly that great is his showmanship in the ring. I have to admit iam an a rjj fan through the years and he is more fun to watch in the ring than floyd which results in adding more hype in him as a fighter. But that's just it, and he is all done now. and I hope he will use more of his god given intelligence in his future fights and learn the lesson that he can't lower both of his hands defensively like he use to in the lower weights. because this time he is doen's have that superior handspeed like he use to have. And for Floyd, He has yet to prove his greatness, by Beating all the top contenders.