Quote Originally Posted by luvfightgame
I think Shane is a real tough fight for PBF. Overall, I also think that if PBF wants to be considered as an all time great he needs to keep fighting. Although his record is perfect he hasn't had a career defining fight. He hasn't shown that he's the full package. I really think Mosley beats PBF or Mosley brings out the best of PBF and the career defining fight happens.

Shane is fast and strong and has very good stamina. You mentioned Zab, Baldo, and ODH. Those 3 fights 2 he waited for the guy to gas out, and one he outran the whole time. Those 2 strategies won't work against Shane and I don't think he can ko him. So he would have to fight offensively to win. If that's the case it's a crackin fight. I give the advantage to Shane cause I have seen a lot more offense and willingness to fight from him.
I thought ODH was a career defining victory for him. He went up to 154 to beat the best fighter in the division despite having a huge size disadvantage. On top of that it came against the only 6 division champion in boxing history who was more hungry for this fight (because of his past failures in big fights) than any other fight in his career. If ODH was not a career defining victory I don't know how Mosley is.