At 147, and at this point, I'd say Cotto. But, I'll reserve final judgement until after their next fights. If JLC comes in shape, and brings his A-game, and Hatton can walk through him, then Hatton would have a shot. On the other hand, If Hatton loses, or barely pulls it out, he wouldn't stand a chance against a younger, stronger, more aggressive version of Castillo(Cotto), at a heavier weight.

Would have like to seen this fight at 140, and would still like to see it. Even if both guys lose, or just one does, their styles would make for an exciting fight, that I would still want to see.