Tszyu vs Cotto would be great. Tszyu gets my nod, only because Cotto is more conventional than Hatton, and Tszyu would land cleaner shots on cotto.


As for the argument about Tszyu-Hatton, Tszyu was still great, but had too long of a lay-off, and Hatton and his camp came in with the right style, and game plan to wear Tszyu out. Hats off to Hatton. If the fight was earlier in their careers, you could always say Tszyu, because he was a beast, but it could be countered that at that time Hatton wasn't ready, or experienced enough. Pure speculation, but I'd say Tszyu if the fight was when Tszyu beat Mitchell the first time, then beat Zab.