Tszyu vs Cotto

[zhubin]

Exactly what has Cotto done in his career so far to make someone pick him over Tszyu?

Exactly what had Ricky Hatton done in his career prior to his fight with Kostya

That wasn't a prime Tszyu, that was an old inactive Tszyu. There's a significant difference.

You mean a 35 year old Kostya who hadn't fought in 7 months before meeting Hatton was inferior to the 35 year old Kostya who hadn't fought in 22 months before destoying Sharmba Mitchell Sorry bro, but that excuse doesn't fly around here anymore.

Neither one of those versions of Tszyu was a prime Tszyu. I don't see how what you just typed disproves anything I said before.

Because unbeknownst to you, a fighter's prime doesn't only last a fraction of a moment. It's pretty much common sense. If a fighter is able to produce consistent victories at a high level, the 'oh he wasn't in his prime' excuse goes right out the window. It's fans like you that try to say a fighter's prime is between two dates when they didn't lose, so that any argument against a fighter losing can be rebutted by saying, 'oh, well um, he wasn't in his prime.' Newsflash; great fighters in the prime of their career can lose fights. It happens all the time.

You're taking this thread completely off-topic, since this is supposed to be about Cotto vs. Tszyu.... but I'll play along.

So are you saying that Kostya Tszyu was in the prime of his career when he fought Ricky Hatton?

LMAO at this guy getting all mad

I think Samson is on the rag right now.

I'd say Kostya was in his prime when he fought Hatton. He looked as good as he ever did the fight just before that against Sharmba Mitchell. IMO you can take Kostya from '99, '00, '02, '03, or '04 and the result is still the same, just as IMO you can take Tyson from any year and he'll always lose to Evander. Again, just my opinion.

So u think hatton beats a 99 tszyu in australia with a non biased ref and crowd? Good luck convincing me of that.

Bingo! Listen...at the end of the day he lost to Hatton...but the conditions for that fight where FAR from ideal. And no...a fighter who is 35 years old and coming off injuries and long stretches of inactivity is not "prime." It's a testament to his ability that he performed as well as he did at that point of his career. As far as Tszyu vs. Cotto...i think Cotto has talent...but i am not yet completely sold on him. One thing we do know is that Miguel is a bit chinny...and Tszyu was a tremendous puncher and deadly accurate...so i think Cotto would be in trouble. I would have loved to see Kostya vs. Floyd...that truly would have been a fantastic match. It's true...Floyd is damn hard to hit with his speed and defense...but Kostya in his prime was a devastating puncher, extremely accurate, fantastic timing, smart, and in tremendous shape. So i think it would have been a very intriguing fight.