does calzaghe get credit for beating Eubank?

[JonesJrMayweather]

i remember that chris was a shell but Jc did look good...but it was obvious that chris wasn't the same fighter...just wondering does anyone give JC credit for beating him...

Certainly.

While Eubank was past it...I'm not so sure that I'd say he was a shell or a ghost or something like that. He was still fundamentally with it enough to give Joe a good 12. I was really impressed with both men in that fight.

I think many fail to give Calzaghe his dues & hunt waaaaay to many reasons to justify it.

nah i don't that many reasons..i give him his credit for undefeated and winning all of his fights he's great..but he's not as great as his record might suggest...

That was a broad statement...not directed at you.

nah nah i know it wasn't aimed at me...i was giving my opinion on the part that I do understand..that many do expect too much from fighters..

he has to beat lacy, then fight bhop, winky, kessler all inside 18months etc etc etc....

while it doesn't take that much for me to be completely sold on him as "great" or on eubanks' level i would like to see him fight and beat one of the better experienced americans...not taylor either because he's just as flawed and green as lacy and would be moving up to fight JC