does calzaghe get credit for beating Eubank?

[Preme]

i remember that chris was a shell but Jc did look good...but it was obvious that chris wasn't the same fighter...just wondering does anyone give JC credit for beating him...

about as much credit as I give hatton for beating KT....very little.....

Yes Tszyu was shot to pieces - everybody said it before the fight and knew Hatton would win

All those wars Tszyu had and those hard 2 years rest he had had and that terrible perfomance against Sharmba Mitchell all added up to an easy night and a foregone conclusion for Hatton

...and yes JC deserves little credit for beating Eubank. Coz Eubank had only had 17 World title victories and it wasn't as if Calzaghe was making a huge step up to fight a legend that would have 2 awesome performnaces against the World Crusier weight champion afterwards or that JC had trained to fight Steve Collins or anything

Agree with Hatton part but disagree with Eubank part yes he had good victorys in *the past* but really BIG H me and you know it wasn't prime one and to top it off having to lose like 11 pounds or something like that in a week how good can somebody be when there that much weight drained ??

in the gran scheme of things 11pounds isnt that geat deal of wieght to drop since the re-hydrate after the weigh in...

even if eubank didn't have to drop weight he was stilpast it..

but you got to look at it ice as this... joe was very young in boxing terms... cweight drop is normally a problem in later rounds wehn a boxer fades, eubank didn't.... in no way to i give joe the cred for beating him as if he beat the prim eubank... but the ring exp,savy, skill was amassive thing for hoe to overcome, even in the early rounds where a 'weight drained' fighter is expected to make the most of things, joe still won convincingly...

like i said tho, chris was old as joe was young... it was still a big big win imo