Quote Originally Posted by Preme
i think people are kidding them selves if they think winky could of beaten him or even posed problems...

even now winky has not beaten an astablished middle weight... to those who thught he beat taylor (and i am one of them) it was damn close against a guy who was lazy and fought with little heart... prime hopkins and roy would of made easy work of winky...


I thik calzaghe would of pushed roy to his limits at SMW... if we are talking prime for prime when calzaghe was able to sparr and keep tuned up his speedpower, fittness foot work and raw skill wouldof been a huge test for roy... honestly, for those who write calzaghe off as a no chances, if that was the ase why would roy turn down over $5.5m? he knew calzaghe was a huge test

at LHW, ezzard chales would of been a huge test for him and i would have to sit on the fence for that..

IMO Billy Conn had what it took to beat him, no dobt in my mind. I think billy is a very very underrated fighter, a true great.
Jones is too good for Calzaghe and Calzaghe eats too many right hands and Jones has terrific right hand and great left hook too talented too quick too much power for Calzaghe.