Where do you put Castillo all time as a lighweight?

[El Gamo]

Who are the other fighters outside that list SweetPea.?

Tszyu and Carbajal are two obvious ones that I forgot the first time around. Camacho might be up there too.

Like I said before, Castillo is a nice fighter. He's had a good career. But his crowning achievement is beating Corrales on a night when he didn't even bother to make weight.

You make your points well but aside from the guys you have mentioned,JLC could be up there too. He has beaten Lazcano,Bazan,Stevie Johnston,gave PBF his toughest fight and arguable beat him,beat Corrales,Joel Casamayor and if he beats Hatton too,thats pretty darn impressive.

I'm not saying hes an ATG of any kind and may be I was pushing it saying he was one of the best of this generation but his accomplishments are not to be looked down upon. His list of fights is like a whos who at lightweight from this generation.