Where do you put Castillo all time as a lighweight?

[THE THIRD MAN]

Who are the other fighters outside that list SweetPea.?

Tszyu and Carbajal are two obvious ones that I forgot the first time around. Camacho might be up there too.

Like I said before, Castillo is a nice fighter. He's had a good career. But his crowning achievement is beating Corrales on a night when he didn't even bother to make weight.

I guess its a bit off the point but how hard is it really to break down Tsyzu's resume. We all think of him as this great fighter, and he was, but what are his best wins? Judah? The most mocked boxer of our generation. Its still a good win, but its not a great win. Other than that, Mitchell, Hurtado, Ruelas, Tackie, Gonzalez, ancient Chavez. Its not bad, its not murderers row. I can't say he has three wins as good as Johnston, Casamayor, and Corrales, leven eaving out the fact that Castillo could have easily gotten a win over PBF the first time out. Its hard to say if he's one of the best of our generation, but I guess I rate him higher than you do.

When talking about Tszyu's resume remember 50% of all his fights were against World Champions and he beat a former World Champion in only his 4th pro fight! A lot of guys ducked him too!