Who's the best current Welterweight?

[CutMeMick]

I'm a little surprised that I'm the only one who has even brought up Clottey's name (I had him at #5).

What has Paul Williams done at this point to be above Clottey? He hasn't fought anyone really legit yet. If he beats Margarito, obviously I'd bump him up to the Top 5, but he hasn't done it yet.

I think Cottos #1, Baldomir #2, Margarito #3, SSM #4.

Being that PBF last fought at Light Middle thats where you would have to rate him, IMO.

Baldomir is fighting Vernon Forrest at 154, so if you're removing Floyd, do you need to remove Baldomir?

The fight hasn't happened. What if the fight falls through?
If the fight happens then rightly so Baldomir will be rated at 154.
PBF-ODLH happened already there for thats where I rate them both.
Same applies to someone like David Haye whos a Cruiser but last fought at Heavy. therefor I rate him as a Heavy.

That's fair enough. Makes sense.
I just wasn't sure if you were forgetting that Baldomir was moving up to 154.

Nah! I know about the fight...
I'm actually leaning more towards Baldomir judging them by their last outings is what leads me to say Baldomirs gonna win.