Elway is a great QB, but he doesn't make it to the last two Superbowls w/o Terrel Davis steam rolling over teams. Winning superbowls is important, but not that big of deal. Some guys just never play on a team with that much talent....Troy Aikman was on one of most dominant teams in NFL history and one two superbowls but I wouldn't even put the guy in my top 10 QB's. Same with Namath or Sims. Dilfer/Rypien/Williams the list of superbowl winning QB's that aren't on anybody's ATG list goes on forever. Montana was a great QB, but if we are just talking about individual skill, he is just outside the top 5 to me.