Whilst hatton in fairness has gone to the us and fought a couple of times, i don't see how that makes you a better fighter.

Calzaghe is a much better P4P fighter than hatton is - Hatton can only really brawl, when he ca,e up agasint a good boxe rin collazo he struggled bad. Calzaghe can do it all, he does need to get a few better guys in the ring with him though...