Who got screwed over the most....Castillo or Collazo?

[ono]

Before you read on just be aware tha i'm just interested in what my fellow saddonians opinions are on this topic. I already have my answer in my mind.

Just basically want to know in your opinion which was the worst decision....

Mayweathers 116-111, 115-111, 115-111 UD over Castillo

or...

Hatton's 115-112, 115-112, 114-113 over Collazo.

[hackey100]

Yes I'm a Ricky fan, but I thought a strong case could be made in his favour against Collazo. Mayweather on the other hand was given a gift, which was why the rematch was made.

[Sugar_Shaw]

I scored the Hatton-Collazo fight 114-113 Hatton
In scored the Mayweather-Castillo fight 115-113 Castillo

[gally]

Ive got to admit i scored them both draws.

[Taeth]

I agree with both verdicts though I don't think Mayweather won as decisively as the scorecards indicated, and it may have been a draw, but Collazo clearly lost his fight because of the KD in the first round.

[Tito BHB]

I had hatton winning by a point.. But i would have allowed a draw.. There was just the one round which i felt could have gone either way..

And thats a fair statement coming from a big collazo fan Check the sig!

But mayweather was beaten by castillo so that wins by a large margin...

Yes the fight was close..But the specific rounds were not.. The rounds taken were equal enough to have a super close fight but each round was clearly one or the others

Peace

[Fire]

hatton beat collazo 7 rounds to 5 ...collazo was the only one knocked down....

even if it was 6 to 6 hatton still wins by the collazo knock down

no way in h*ll collazo won 7rds. to 5 which is the only way he could have won....

as far as maywether-castillo... mayweather owned him the second fight so i think that should show who is the better fighter....

[ICB]

Before you read on just be aware tha i'm just interested in what my fellow saddonians opinions are on this topic. I already have my answer in my mind.

Just basically want to know in your opinion which was the worst decision....

Mayweathers 116-111, 115-111, 115-111 UD over Castillo

or...

Hatton's 115-112, 115-112, 114-113 over Collazo.

Ricky done enough the knockdown edged it Collazo done good but not quite good enough and Hatton won lucky for Ricky that he scored the knockdown because that was basically his saviour in the scoring.

And i thought Castillo just edged out a victory.

[Poom]

Castillo,

Collazo didn't do enough , yes he had a great 12th round but he didn't do enough to win.

[Gandalf]

hatton beat collazo 7 rounds to 5 ...collazo was the only one knocked down....

even if it was 6 to 6 hatton still wins by the collazo knock down

no way in h*ll collazo won 7rds. to 5 which is the only way he could have won....

as far as maywether-castillo... mayweather owned him the second fight so i think that should show who is the better fighter....

Hatton won by merit of the knockdown. Without then its a draw.

Either way it was a very lacklustre performance from Hatton...

[Kel]

hatton beat collazo 7 rounds to 5 ...collazo was the only one knocked down....

even if it was 6 to 6 hatton still wins by the collazo knock down

no way in h*ll collazo won 7rds. to 5 which is the only way he could have won....

as far as maywether-castillo... mayweather owned him the second fight so i think that should show who is the better fighter....

Thats not the point though is it. We are talking the FIRST fight it really don't matter who won the second. I don't know why people bring the bloody rematch up in these cases :P

[Gandalf]

hatton beat collazo 7 rounds to 5 ...collazo was the only one knocked down....

even if it was 6 to 6 hatton still wins by the collazo knock down

no way in h*ll collazo won 7rds. to 5 which is the only way he could have won....

as far as maywether-castillo... mayweather owned him the second fight so i think that should show who is the better fighter....

Thats not the point though is it. We are talking the FIRST fight it really don't matter who won the second. I don't know why people bring the bloody rematch up in these cases :P

Castillo did do enough to win the first fight IMO. Floyd was lacking something and Castillo kept on coming and landed decent shots. Castillo's aggresion was the deciding factor for me.

[Pugilistic]

castillo deserved the victory agianst mayweather in the first fight

collazo lost to hatton in my opinion

[JonesJrMayweather]

in the end collazo got screwed worst because he didn't get his rematch as the champ should..floyd gave castillo another shot and he clearly lost the rematch...

[JT Rock]

What tends to get me pissed more than anything about people lamely going back 5 years to discredit Mayweather is..... YOU CANT REVERSE THE DESICIONS, YOU CANT REWRITE THE PAST.. People act like its the 1st time a questionable desicion has ever been rendered

The HONORABLE thing that can be done is a rematch... Floyd unhesitantly granted Jose a rematch to do right by the fans and Castillo...

I like Ricky a lot he is a nice fella. But I get so Arsed when people throw around the words HONOR and PRIDE, when in fact he Promised Collazzo a rematch on national television and then renegged.. I asked a few zealous Hatton fans why no rematch? they say well its old news, been there done that, he beat him, why bother for another fight...

My next question is. Where is the Honor and pride with the desire to fulfill your promises made and silence the critics who thought he lost