Quote Originally Posted by Beanflicker
Ok, here is my question to all you people who make these top p4p lists. How can you guys rank guys like Henry Armstrong, Sandy Saddler, Willie Pep, ect ect ect, SO HIGH when you may have seen only 2 or 3 of their fights (or, in many cases, none at all). What is the justification for having these guys so high? Do you rank them based on online and newspaper articles written about them? I don't understand it really...
That's a damn good question. Armstrong, Saddler and Pep are one thing. I want to know how many times the poster who made this list saw Eder Jofre, Joe Jeanette, George Dixon, Tommy Loughran and Jim Driscoll fight, that he's able to rank them?