I pick Mayweather. I mean I hate him with all my heart but he won against Oscar De La Hoya. Fair and square as much as I hate to say it. I've not seen Hatton to much except when he fought Casitllo which I did not like that fight, to much clinching for me but anyway Mayweather has that great slick defence that everybody talks about. It worked against the aggresive De La Hoya. I think of whatever weight class they choosed to do it. De La Hoya to me still has the better punch then Jose Luis Casitllo. So if DLH could not fade Mayweather, Why Hatton?