All time P4P contender - 10 (20.4%)
World Class fighter - 26 (53.1%)
Good fighter who scraped a world title in a bad era - 8 (16.3%)
Decent British hometown fighter but little more - 2 (4.1%)
Bum! - 3 (6.1%)

OK, so on the whole I think we can safely say that Joe Calzaghe is a quality act, however, he lacks the credentials to back up the P4P rating that some people give him... I must confess that this was the result that I was expecting, as I am a Joe C fan, however take many of these claims for P4P greatness with a pinch of salt.

However, I hope to be able to post a poll on Nov 4 asking whether Joe's victory over Mikkel Kessler makes him a P4P great, however, until I watch that fight happen, I am not going to be as presumptuous as to think that would be the result.... We got months of debate before that happens!!!!