I think Reid edged the fight by a point or two. But it was close. And I don't really have a problem with Ottke winning. 115-113 seemed reasonable. But one judge had it a ridicules 117-112 for Ottke. The ref did seem to be a little against Reid. Warning him about everything. But if you watch the fight you'll see he was also warning Ottke. The knock down was clearly a slip. The reason people labeled this a robbery was cuz Ottke had already said he was retiring soon. And a lot of people wanted to see him lose. They did not want to see him retire undefeated. They felt Reid had done enough to win. But didn't get it.