I think with his accomplishments as a MW alone give him consideration as an ATG...Now with a onesided demolition of Tarver and close but definitive win over one of the most technical fighters of his era I dont know how he isn't in a top 15 P4P argument...He is the most dominant MW since Hagler, he beat two of the three best WW's of his time in ODH and Tito, beat the best Jr MW and LHW and if he does beat the Calzaghe/Kessler winner then I dont know how he isn't mentioned with the likes of SRL etc.