Floyd would be higher because of the fighters hes beaten. Where would Hatton be if he beat Mayweather and lost to De La Hoya? would De La Hoya be higher than Floyd or would he be lower than Hatton. The P4P list is looked on in terms of how long you have been Champ and how many titles have you won in different divisions and who you have beaten its complicated as there is no one precise measure of who is P4P no 1. Mayweather is there now because he has beat legitimate contenders and Champions form 130- 154, Hatton has only fought at 140 and 147 and hasn't had a very long reign as champ and looking at his fight resume it is not all that impressive