It was not the worst decision I have ever seen but IMO Castillo won the fight....I had him up by 2 rds....Also it depends I guess on how you score a fight.....He was the underdog...He was in Floyds face...He brought Floyd to the limit....Pushed the action....backed Floyd up at times....But you know the old expression....You hve to convincingly beat the champion.....So I guess in the eyes of the judges was not enough