To me holyfield will always been a total ATG, im not sure where he ranks and i don't think i would have him in the top 10 of all time.

but he is up there, as for winning this fight i don't think i would consider him any higher than he is now (where evr i have him lol) legecys are rgeat, but to me they don't place a fighter any higher or lower, they re-enforce an argument about where u have already placed him, they are sometime there to showa fighter could do things that others might question.

mainly p4p great lists i rank people by what they done in their prime, because to me whats what its for, like current p4p list its what guys are doing now, not 4 years ago...

it seems some people forget holyfield was never really a heavyweight, he was a cruiser but moved up for the big fights. going from cruiser to heavy isnt like going from welter to Light-middle, or middle to super middle, there is no few pound jump, your talking much much bigger and stronger guys to compete with. evander never really possed the power at heavyweight he needed to complement his style, it was his true warrior spirit that got him a lot of his wins (ofc his talent too) but lacking the power he really had to dig deep to get some of his great wins...

The third bowe fight, wasn't there something badly up with holyfield then? i know forman wouldn't shut up about his hear, that he shouldn't be in there, holyfield looked in bad shape very very early on, someting your not accustomed to seeing in someone like him...