The judges thought he lost to Tito & Shane twice. A lot of boxing fans thought he should have been 2-1 in these 3 fights instead of 0-3 as the record book shows. So the question would be, does he get kept out of the hall of fame because some judges might have been wrong in 2 of his biggest fights?

Hopkins was just too big for him but I think Oscar deserves some credit for taking that challenge.