Hall of Famer:

1. Never dodged anyone despite the fact that his popularity allowed him to.
2. Was the first fighter to outbox and expose then undefeated P4Per Felix Trinidad. (i don't care that the judges went the other way anymore than i care that they gave Hearns a draw in the 2nd leonard fight)
3. Great comeback victory against then undefeated P4Per ike quartey
4. Excellent performace in Mosley II (as i mentioned, i don't take decisions as gospel)
5. convincingly defeated chavez, Miguel Angel Gonzalez, Jesse James Leija, Genaro Hernandez, Rafael Ruelas, John John Molina, Jorge Paez, Ricardo Mayorga, Fernando Vargas, Arturo Gatti...all top flight fighters

Only Hopkins KO'd him. Mosely and Whitiaker (arguably) narrowly outboxed him and Mayweather schooled hm at the end. But that's not enough to keep him out.