Quote Originally Posted by Memphis
Right so we cant talk about Castillo who at worst came very close to beating Mayweather a long time ago but we can talk about Eamonn Magee who had one good round against Hatton a long time ago.

Its relevant if someone thinks its relevant, thats the bottom line.

If Hatton had rematched Collazo and beaten him soundly would people disregard his first effort? of course they wouldnt. It still offers some insight into what another fighter can achieve, same with Mayweather Castillo 1.
Im not saying you can't bring it up but when people are bringing up first fight they always seem to forget they had a rematch and Mayweather easily won plus if you remember didn't Mayweather have injury to his shoulder in first fight ??


but we can talk about Eamonn Magee who had one good round against Hatton a long time ago.

I didn't talk about it i haven't seen that fight.

If Hatton had rematched Collazo and beaten him soundly would people disregard his first effort? of course they wouldnt. It still offers some insight into what another fighter can achieve, same with Mayweather Castillo 1.

I would have because he would of proved that first time was a fluke and that he properly trained for the rematch but i still think he wouldn't of beat Collazo easy due to Hatton having problems with southpaws he has had that problem since he was an amateur i believe.