Quote Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING
Benn vs Eubank 1
Mugabi vs Hagler
Hearns vs Hagler
Duran vs Barkley
Jake LaMotta vs Sugar Ray Robinson ST Valentines Day Massacre

All these fights were better yes Pavlik vs Taylor was great fight but not top 5 Middleweight fight of all time people are forgetting and getting too over excited.
Disagree. Mugabi-Hagler was a one-sided butt-whipping. It was a pretty good fight, but it would not make my top 10. St Valentines Massacre, again, a one-sided butt-kicking. Duran-Barkley and Hagler-Hearns, definitely better, although I don't necessarily think by much. I haven't seen Benn-Eubanks I, I'll check it out (part of the reason I started this thread was so folks would mention bouts I have not seen). I think there's a pretty good case for Pavlik-Taylor going into the top 5 depending on your criteria.