I think he deserves to be in there not so much for his ability but the way boxing fans reminise about him. He was definately entertainng and was never in a dull fight. His first fight against castillo will be remembered for years. Especially that 10th round. Also talent wise he was the first to beat Freitas and the second to beat Casamayor who many consider to be the man at lightweight now. For me he should be in. Afterall it is the hall of fame and not the hall of talent.