Well you could make the same case for him as Castillo. Both were champions and both were involved in some of the best fights of this generation. IMO he may be a little shy of being in the hall only because if you let him in you have to induct a lot of other guys on the same plateu as him over the years and there have been a lot of guys. Maybe not as much heart but similar accomplishments. If he was to get in I would have no problem with it though. He was great for boxing.