How do you personally rate a fighter?

[CFH]

Personally, I'd lean towards the defensive fighter as the better boxer, but I'd probably rather watch the other guy as his fights would be, to me, more exciting - unless he was just some sloppy brawler.

Thats why I stated they would have the same resume and accomplishments, I agree I would also lean towards the defensive fight but of course we all like to see the KO

I can appreciate both styles, which is what it comes down to. I've watched power punchers involved in some pretty boring fights, and I've seen defensive wizards in some great fights as well.