I think the hesitation most people feel about calling this one comes from having faith in both fighters. They've both proven what they can do in the ring, so it all boils down to which one wants it the most. Cotto has the tenacity to go after SSM like a pit bull in heat, and Shane has the skills, experience, and speed to frustrate Cotto.

Heart goes with Cotto stopping Shane late, but I have to pick SSM by UD. I don't think Shane's old just yet.

Didn't we just have this age argument about Calzaghe?