Quote Originally Posted by LegendBoxing65
Ice, Roy never crushed a great fighter. Virgil Hill by 1998 was not the fighter he was in 1991 when he fought Hearns. Somehow he was not the same. Roy was good but he never wanted to have a chin test by someone like Spinks or Hearns. Guys in the 80s who always tested the other guys chin. Roy took on guys who he knew he could take a punch if he had to. Roy was good but all time great. Hard to say. He doesn't have any great fights. The same as Mosley.
Ice, Roy never crushed a great fighter.

Totally disagree.

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Virgil Hill

Were all great fighters.

Virgil Hill by 1998 was not the fighter he was in 1991 when he fought Hearns. Somehow he was not the same.

He was still great fighter after Hearns fight he went on 13 winning streak before losing UD to Dariusz Michalczewski then he fought Roy Jones Jr right after and Jones stopped him in 4 rounds and is the only one to ever KO Virgil Hill thats great achievement.


Roy was good but he never wanted to have a chin test by someone like Spinks or Hearns. Guys in the 80s who always tested the other guys chin.

He never had to have chin test because he was that good.


Roy took on guys who he knew he could take a punch if he had to. Roy was good but all time great. Hard to say. He doesn't have any great fights. The same as Mosley.

I totally disagree you keep saying he ducked fighters and ect but who were these *big punchers* he ducked then ??

Roy was good but all time great. Hard to say. He doesn't have any great fights. The same as Mosley.


You don't have to have great fight to be All Time Great he dominated Hall Of Famers and won the World Heavyweight Championship when he started as Middleweight which hadn't be done since early 1900s and your telling me thats not ATG material ??