Quote Originally Posted by Mr140
Ok i will give you that Ice it was a pretty good accomplishment. And your early comment about Eddie Mustafa Muhammad that was Spinks 17 fight he was still learning and he still won a fight with a pretty good champion and won it pretty clearly. Qawi was a good fighter and later went on to Ok Leon and become a Cursierweight champion and Spinks was a very clear winner was not even close. And all those people you just mention for his best wins were not ever in LH so what is your point Roy never faced that great of people at LH his era was worse then Spinks.
And your early comment about Eddie Mustafa Muhammad that was Spinks 17 fight he was still learning and he still won a fight with a pretty good champion and won it pretty clearly.

Won clearly yes but still was a bit of a struggle.

146-138 144-140 145-139

Qawi was a good fighter and later went on to Ok Leon and become a Cursierweight champion and Spinks was a very clear winner was not even close.

Qawi was good but limited due to his size and Spinks was down in that fight and even in that fight it was quite close.

144-141 144-141 144-140


And all those people you just mention for his best wins were not ever in LH so what is your point Roy never faced that great of people at LH his era was worse then Spinks.

My point was Legend was question Roy's legacy so i pointed out the facts Jones still had the same skills he had at lower weights i mean he KO Kelly with his hands behind his back let me put it this way Spinks was good champion Jones was something else.