Its a tough call evander fought past his prime WAY PAST IT, at least mike knew when to get out, people say oh evander got stopped by james toney etc.... and you know what tyson would have lost to toney at his late age too he was horrible he lost to danny williams and i cant even remeber the other horrible fighter he got koed by in his old age. Evander beat the younger challengers, tyson on paper had better skills and more flash kos. Holyfield certainly was more of a warrior great chin and probably would die in the ring. Tyson had some chracter problems, evender had a problem with consistency but on a given night could beat anyone. tyson never avenged a loss, holyfield did, I give the nod to holy but no arguement either way