I agree with ICB on the Reid fight but here's My view SHORT AND SWEET.

Calzaghe an all time great: No

He beat Kessler who his last 5 opponents were world class so brilliant, that was a top performance and should get HIGH recognition for that HOWEVER

He fought 2 contenders, one of which never won the show and another nearly got KO'd in the first round. Overrated Lacy built up by the press. Past it Eubank, on another night could've beaten by Reid, a couple of FORMER world champs and the rest Bums.

So NO IMO Calzaghe has a fir bit of work to do if he wants to be considered an ATG and he can start by booking a flight with BA to Philidelphia to fight in someone else's backyard for a change.

(They go straight from Heathrow Joe)