Quote Originally Posted by Taeth
Whitaker was only impossible to hit by lesser opponents. Chavez and Oscar hit him plenty of times. I think Whitaker was fun to watch, but he was less dynamic than Mayweather. Also there have been a few fights in Mayweather's career where he has decided to make it a brawl and has had as exciting of fights as anyone I've seen like against Ndou, Corley, Sosa, Chavez, Burton. Also Mayweather always does amazing things, A lot of times Whitaker looked kind of like Roy JOnes Jr. and just playing with opponents. I still feel Whitaker didn't have the greatest competition, at least guys who matched up well with him, most of them were very slow and Mayweather would have also handled them with ease(except the guys like Chavez). Also Mayweather is the better athlete, he hits harder than Whitaker and he's faster which makes him more exciting because he looks so quick and crisp. When its all said and done I think its a toss up.
But it sounds like you're leaning toward Mayweather