Quote Originally Posted by Mr140
Well i not getting in to it with legacy and all that but i have to disagree with a few thing Winky i would not do well at 175 pounds to much weight and he lose to some champions at LH. Then there is Trinidad he did alright but besides Joppy he got killed at the weight. Oscar should of never even been a champion at the weight and should not even had fought Bernard but that being said B hop has a good legacy but out Oscar and Trinadad wins he would of been not even near what he is today and both Oscar and Trinidad were just to far out of there weight classes to tell you the truth and so was Winkey at Lightheavyweight he looked way out of shape at 175 he is good at Middleweight but 175 he is just to fat at that weight to tell you the truth.
Trinidad KTFO a MW champ in Joppy, who went the distance with Hopkins and Taylor, nad beat a top contender in Cherifi. Hardly out of his depth at 160.
Winky didnt fight at 175 he fought at 170, closer to SMW. Now tell me how many SMW would beat Winky? Not many.
As for Oscar, yeah he shouldnt have been champ, but he was easy a top 5 guy at MW.