IMO If you beat the P4P Number 1, you surely must become P4P number 1 - how could you not??
You have proved you are better than P4P Number 1 therefore you must = P4P Number 1
IMO If you beat the P4P Number 1, you surely must become P4P number 1 - how could you not??
You have proved you are better than P4P Number 1 therefore you must = P4P Number 1
God is a concept, By which we can measure, Our pain, I'll say it again, God is a concept, By which we can measure, Our pain, I don't believe in magic, I don't believe in I-ching, I don't believe in bible, I don't believe in tarot, I don't believe in Hitler, I don't believe in Jesus, I don't believe in Kennedy, I don't believe in Buddha, I don't believe in mantra, I don't believe in Gita, I don't believe in yoga, I don't believe in kings, I don't believe in Elvis, I don't believe in Zimmerman, I don't believe in Beatles, I just believe in me!!
He beat Kostya who was in the top 5 pound for pound,beat castillo who and i could b wrong was just outside the pond for pound,11 or 12,so if he beats the number 1 then of course he is gonna b number 1......,plus he's undefeated..any1 that begs to differ,either hates hatton or doesnt hav a clue about boxing...
It depends if you rate Floyd p4p number 1 or not . They say he is universally recognised as such but I cant give him that title cuz of the guys he's fought . Its either Hopkins or Calzaghe . Floyds top 3 but I dont think he can beat Hatton
floyd is number 1,simple as that,most fans,magazines ,boxers and the boxing community hav him as number 1,so beating him makes u number 1,even if he was number 2 and ricky beat him then i still think he would go up to number 1...i really dont c how any1 can beg to differ...,floyd has never lost and to be the best then u beat the best....
Many people thought he lost to a washed up De La Hoya and a limited Castillo.Originally Posted by fin
Hattons also unbeaten and his stoppage win over Tszyu stands out as more impressive than anyone Floyds beat .
Ricky wins on sat then he's number 1...
Originally Posted by Fenster
for the list Fenster, i'm suprsied J M Marquez was on the list back then I thought he didn't really become a p4p star until the Barrera win. Also Glen Johnson at number 10. I guess it must have been following his win over Tarver but still I would never have considered Johnson a p4p star at any time.
Presumably Jones had already suffered his KO losses by June 05 hence him not being anywhere in the top 10?
Calzaghe has fought 1 good opponent in 44 and you say he is P4P number 1Originally Posted by GAME
, No can do.
CC fin that view was perfect.![]()
nice one Fenster....Originally Posted by Fenster
as WelshDevilRob has remembered...... he was no1 around that time on a few lists... all the oz sites rated him at no oneand i remember one american site that had him at no 1 was boxing talk... just before Hatton beat him
i can prove it if needed but really CBA'd to![]()
If Hatton wins, he has to be No.1. It would be possible to beat the No.1 and not become No.1 yourself, like say if the No.1 went up a division to far and fought a big guy (if ODLH had beaten PBF in a close contest or by overpowering him, I wouldn't have considered him No.1).Originally Posted by BIG H
If he beats number 1 he should become number 1
Originally Posted by WelshDevilRob
Can't say I ever remember Kostya being number 1 P4P.....#1 at 140 but not P4P
Hidden Content IN CASE THEY ALL FORGOT WHAT REAL HEAVYWEIGHT POWER WAS!!!
I knew I wasn't going completely senile, thanks Saddo.Originally Posted by Saddo
Thats a contradiction if I ever saw one.Originally Posted by GAME
If Hatton beats Floyd, I'd have to wait for Pacquiao-Marquez to make a clear call.
If Pacquiao clearly beats Marquez, I think you have to put Pac at #1 over Hatton.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks