Respectfully I'd still give it to Pavlik, as Miranda and Taylor were both supposed to expose Pavlik as a fake. And whether or not he is one, they didn't do it, and were considered the #1 and 2 threats in that division, and Abraham to I suppose. Hardly anyone in the boxing world gave Hatton a chance to beat Mayweather, and although his win over Hatton was impressive, Hatton was hardly considered a threat at WW. The win over Oscar was great also, and is a good argument for Floyd to get the honors. I wouldn't be upset if Floyd gets Fighter of the Year though. JMO