There is some irrational hate for Mayweather but a lot of Mayweather's super fans act like all criticism is irrational hate.

For example, I did criticize him for a while, from his time at 135 after Castillo through his pointless stop at 147, and up to his last four fights. But I don't criticize him anymore, having Baldomir, Judah, ODLH, and Hatton as his last four opponents is just fine.

Doesn't mean Hatton was the number one guy he should have fought IMO. You act like everyone says Hatton wasn't really a welter after the fight, a lot of people like me said that beforehand. I would have rather him fought Cotto because I feel like Cotto's a whole lot more dangerous of a fighter but I'm not going to criticize him that much for taking a fight versus a guy like Hatton, still a good fighter, just not as dangerous as Cotto imo.

And your criticism of Cotto's record at 147 is a bit ridiculous IMO. Maybe you're just acting like one of the irrational Mayweather haters in regards to Cotto but either way it doesn't hold up. A lot of people, not me, but a lot of people thought Judah would beat Cotto, partly because he, at least for a while, fought well against PBF giving him one of his tougher fights. And the Mosley thing, come on.

Shane Mosley then gets the shot at Cotto when he hadn't fought since near the beginning of the year against Collazo who was coming off a loss to Ricky Hatton and wasn't anywhere near the rankings to take on Cotto so Mosley gets there on star power.

Collazo was coming off a questionable loss to Hatton, Mosley whitewashed him, wasn't close. And since when did anybody care about ratings.

Sure Judah's got problems and people can say things to minimize that win but so do all the other fighters on your list for Cotto to fight. Clottey's never beaten anybody, Cintron's a head case who's never beaten anybody, Margarito's a flat out bum to most of the Floyd fans. Williams is the most respected of the four but still not the most tested guy out there.

Either way, I find it hard to see how anybody could criticize Cotto's record at 147 and the group of fighters he's chosen to fight, certainly not the Mosley fight.

Not to say that there isn't stupid hate for Floyd-although I don't know why all Floyd fans take the bait all the time-but I definitely don't agree with all your points. Also floyd's the best fighter in boxing, he's gonna be held to a higher standard. Just like any other sport.