Absolutely not. Not even close. His only world class opposition was Lewis, and though he fought a great fight, he didn't win. The rest of his opponents were, as Mick says, not even close to HOF caliber. If he had remained injury-free and dominated the division for the past decade, then you could give him a pass for the sorry state of the division. But given that he was only around for a few years, he's just not going to be remembered in boxing history.