Floyd hands down deserved this honour....and YES i know that Cotto has had a GREAT year and fair play to him. But Remember PBF has gone up in weight to win a title at 154 against ODLH which for sure was impressive i dont care that oscar was older he still had the power and strengh advantage and PBF overcame that. Then he knocked out Hatton which i never really saw happening in a million years, and remember how many people even on here took Hatton to win that fight. So yes this is deserved IMO.