Forget Mayweather as fighter of the year. I think its between Cotto and Pavlik. Pavlik did knock the two best Middleweights in the world OUT! While Cotto beat up on Judah then eeked out a SD win against Mosley. So maybe because of the way that Pavlik won against such good fighters he deserves it. Or maybe Cotto does for beating freakin Sugar Shane Mosley. I dunno.