Quote Originally Posted by JT Rock
Quote Originally Posted by Tam Seddon
But he is the best fighter at 140.
Agreed... But Malignaggi and Witter sure pose a huge threat form a stylistic standpoint

Quote Originally Posted by Tam Seddon

He beat the best the weight class had to offer in Jose Luis Castillo.
A lot of people thought he would win that fight and Hatton got him out there in 4 rounds.
Disagree whole heartedly... You cant call a fighter who was grossly inactive due to not making weight, moving up and getting a gift desicion from a fighter with only 16 pro fights in Herman Njougo.

Castillo was shot to pieces and wasnt even close to being a former shell of himself

He will beat anybody at 140 mark my words. The only threat to him there now would be Juan Diaz if he moved up. Thats a career defining fight for Ricky.
See my 1st reply in reference to Witter and Malignaggi who both deserve a shot at Hatton, especially Paulie if he wins next week
[/quote] Sorry Tam but i totally agree with JT on this one, Castillo only had 1 fight at Jr Welterweight before the Hatton fight, and didn't look impressive by any means. Castillo was at his best at Lightweight.