They got it wrong. Mayweather has 2 good wins but none relevant to his rankings as a 147 pounder and he was heavy favourite in both.Or at least expected to win.

Pavlik went into his fights v a then thought of murderous punching Miranda,who was seen as THE dangerman and HOT favourite and Kelly ripped him to shreds and smashed his myth. Now Miranda is "1dimensional" and"can't fight going backwards" yet NO-ONE said that before the Kelly fight. Then he fights the LINEAR AND TRUE 160 pound champ who had 3 close fights with 2 Hall of Famers and made them both look bad and Kelly KTFO him out.2 HUGE,shock wins,earning him the lineal title. THAT is FOTY for me. I'd have Mayweather joint second with Cotto at best.